For Agencies

Agency OffersWebsite PacksPartner Program

Services

SEOLocal SearchCitationsWeb DesignPaid AdsContentVideoeCommerceAuto RepairWater DamageWebsite SpeedAll Services

Websites

By IndustryWebsite DesignsYour Name WebsiteNonprofit Websites

Work

PortfolioClientsAwardsVideo Games

Tools

All Tools and PricesRASLLMS.txtShop DeskFree Tools

Resources

BlogCitation SitesPodcastsWebsite GuideFree SEO Course

About

AboutProcessContactJoin Us
Home / Blog
The Daily Desk · Local Search · November 21, 2026

Two Ways a Not-at-Fault Claim Gets Paid, for Auto Shops

When a crash isn't your fault, the claim can go through the other driver's insurer or your own collision coverage. Each path pays differently. Both paths side by side for auto shops, with the state rules behind them and why this question costs advertisers $82 a click. Updated November 2026.

Published · 2026-11-21
Reading Time · 5 min
Author · , Founder

Keep Clickflame in your Google results

Two Ways a Not-at-Fault Claim Gets Paid, for Auto Shops
The Short Version

When a crash isn't your fault, you can claim against the other driver's insurer or use your own collision coverage. Their insurer pays with no deductible, but only after it accepts fault. Your own insurer moves on your policy, takes the deductible, then collects from the other side and should chase your deductible too. If you run an auto shop, explain both paths on one page. Injury firms own this search, and a driver with a damaged car still needs a shop.

What Changed

Their Insurer or Yours

Two drivers get rear-ended on the same street. One claims against the other driver's insurer, pays no deductible, and waits for that company to accept fault. The other uses her own collision coverage, pays her deductible, and gets the car into a shop sooner. Her insurer then goes after the other company for the money.

Both drivers got paid. They just took different roads, at different speeds.

That fork is the real answer to how insurance works when a crash isn't your fault. You don't get one claim. You get a choice of two, and each one pays on its own terms.

It's also a question an auto shop can answer better than most of page one. On Google's first page for it in November 2026, the eight regular results came from three injury law firms, Nolo, Progressive, an insurance agency, Reddit and Quora. No repair shop. Fault and injuries belong with a lawyer. The car, the deductible and the rental are where a shop knows the ground.

Path One, the Other Driver's Insurer

This is a third party claim. You file against the at-fault driver's liability coverage, and you aren't that company's customer.

The upside is real. Texas says you don't pay a deductible on a claim against another driver's insurer. The same guide says that insurer will pay for you to rent a car, for the time it thinks a repair should take.

The catch is that the money waits on fault. Until the other company agrees its driver caused the crash, nothing moves. Texas also warns that its prompt payment law doesn't apply when another driver's insurer is paying. That company has to act in good faith, but the deadlines that protect you with your own insurer don't bind it the same way. Appraisal, the usual tool for a fight over the number, can't be used against another person's insurer either.

So this path is best when fault is plain, the other driver reported the crash, and their insurer calls back.

A silver Pontiac G6 strapped down on a flat trailer, seen from behind, on a street in Hemet
A Pontiac G6 loaded and headed to the shop. Which insurer pays for that ride is often the driver's first question. Photo by Supercanic.

Path Two, Your Own Collision Coverage

Here you claim on your own policy, even though you didn't cause the crash. You need collision coverage for this. Texas says that if the other insurer won't pay, your company will probably try to collect from it.

You pay the deductible up front. Texas gives the math plainly. On a $1,500 claim with a $500 deductible, the insurer pays $1,000.

Getting that deductible back is called subrogation. Your insurer steps into your shoes and bills the other side. California says that if your insurer pursues subrogation, it must include your deductible, and if it won't, it must tell you. Any recovery is generally shared in proportion. You can chase the deductible yourself, but California suggests talking to your insurer first so you don't hurt its case.

The upside is speed and rules. California requires an insurer to acknowledge a claim within 15 days and accept or deny it within 40 days of proof of claim. Texas sets 15 days to acknowledge and 15 business days to decide once it has what it needs, with up to 45 days when it needs more time.

One gap catches people. On your own policy, California says a rental is covered only if you bought rental coverage.

A $4,000 Repair Both Ways

Take a worked example with a $4,000 repair and a $500 deductible. These numbers are an illustration, not a quote.

StepTheir insurerYour collision coverage
You pay at the start$0$500
Insurer pays the shop$4,000, once fault is accepted$3,500
RentalPaid for a reasonable repair timeOnly with rental coverage
Deductible backNothing to get backUp to $500, if subrogation succeeds
Main riskDelay or denial on faultWaiting months for the $500

Neither column wins every time. A clean rear-end hit with a responsive insurer favors the left column. A disputed crash, a slow adjuster or an uninsured driver favors the right one.

Rates, Fault Splits and Uninsured Drivers

Three things change the math after the claim is filed. Each one depends on the state, so a page that skips the state name skips the answer.

Your Premium

California is clear. A rating plan can't raise the premium for an accident in which the insured is not at fault. If the police report says you weren't at fault and the insurer decides otherwise, it can only do that after an investigation.

Texas works through renewals instead. Its guide protects drivers from nonrenewal over accidents that can't reasonably be blamed on you, unless there was more than one such claim in 12 months.

Partial Fault

Not at fault is often "mostly not at fault." In Texas, a claimant found more than 50% responsible recovers nothing. Below that line, damages are cut by the claimant's share. In a worked example, a driver found 20% at fault on that $4,000 repair would recover $3,200 from the other side.

No-Fault States

Twelve states and Puerto Rico have no-fault auto insurance laws. In those states your own policy pays first for injury costs. The car is a different story. Nolo notes that vehicle damage can still go against the at-fault driver or through your own collision coverage. So both paths above still apply to the repair, even in Florida or New York.

The Driver Who Hit You Has No Insurance

That happens a lot. The Insurance Research Council estimated that 15.4% of drivers were uninsured in 2023, with 20.4% in California and 14.5% in Texas.

Path one disappears then. In California, uninsured motorist property damage pays the lesser of the car's value or $3,500 when you don't have collision coverage. It needs real contact between the cars, the other driver or plate identified, and a report within 10 business days. If you do carry collision, that coverage pays the loss and the uninsured coverage picks up your collision deductible. Texas says its uninsured coverage won't pay for a hit and run you didn't report to police.

Infographic comparing a claim against the other driver's insurer with a claim on your own collision coverage, state rules on rates, fault splits and uninsured drivers, and the cost per click of not at fault searches against body shop searches
Both claim paths, the rules that change the math, and what each search costs. Free to share with a link back to this guide.

This Searcher Costs More Than a Shop Search

Clickflame pulled Google Ads data for these searches in November 2026, on U.S. monthly averages.

SearchSearches a monthCost a click
car accident lawyer near me201,000$254.96
what to do after a car accident not your fault2,900$82.21
third party claim590$54.11
not at fault accident880$43.22
subrogation40,500$7.94
auto body shop near me201,000$5.91

Lawyers push the top of that list, and they should. Injury cases are their trade. Still, the not at fault question costs about 14 times what auto body shop near me does, and it's asked by someone whose car is damaged right now. A shop that answers it plainly meets that driver before the near me search ever happens.

The exact phrase "how does insurance work when it's not your fault" is small on its own. The page wins on the whole cluster around it, from deductibles to rentals to subrogation.

A black BMW M5 strapped to a flat trailer with a winch at the front, parked in a lot with other cars
A BMW M5 strapped down for the ride to the shop. The tow, the rental and the deductible all land on whichever path the driver picks. Photo by Supercanic.

Put the Fork on Your Site in Five Moves

  1. Lead with the choice. First screen, two columns, their insurer and yours. Use a worked example like the one above, or your own average repair, and label it as an example.
  2. Name your state. Link your Department of Insurance guide beside each rule, and put the month you checked it. A rule with no state is a guess to the reader.
  3. Explain subrogation in one sentence. Most drivers have never heard the word. Tell them the deductible usually comes back later, and that it isn't instant.
  4. Cover the rental gap. Say plainly that a rental on their own policy depends on rental coverage, and that the other insurer pays only after it accepts the claim.
  5. Send injuries to a lawyer. Your page covers the car. Say so, and point fault fights and injury questions elsewhere.

Keep two things off the page. Never promise to cover a deductible, and never tell a driver which insurer will pay before anyone has seen the claim. If a reader asks what to say on the first call, point them to the seven lines to keep off an insurance call.

Clickflame builds pages like this for repair shops, opening with the plain answer and dated state rules. See websites built for auto repair shops.

Shop owners and the agencies that help them can grow with us four ways. Learn, Earn, Team and Scale. Find your letter in LETS.

Evidence

Every number in this story comes from one of these. If a figure is ours, the paragraph says so.

Want This Done for You?

Clickflame builds the websites and runs the local search and ads for service businesses that live on the phone ringing. See websites built for auto repair shops, look at the work, or pick a time and we will look at your numbers with you.

Help Desk Answers

How does insurance work when it's not your fault?

You pick a path. Claim against the other driver's liability insurance, which pays with no deductible once it accepts fault. Or use your own collision coverage, pay your deductible, and let your insurer collect from the other company. Injury claims follow your state's rules, and in no-fault states your own policy pays first.

Should I file with my insurance or theirs?

If fault is clear and their insurer is quick, theirs saves you the deductible. If they stall, deny or have no insurance, your own collision coverage gets the car fixed sooner. The Texas Department of Insurance says your company will probably try to collect from theirs when you file with your own.

Will my rates go up if the accident wasn't my fault?

In California, the law says an insurer's rating plan can't raise your premium for an accident in which you were not at fault. Other states set their own rules, so ask your state's Department of Insurance.

Do I get my deductible back if I wasn't at fault?

Often, but not right away. California says that if your insurer pursues subrogation, it has to include your deductible, and if it won't pursue it, it has to tell you. Recovery can take months, and a fault split can shrink it.

What happens if someone hits you and you only have liability insurance?

Your liability coverage pays for damage you cause, not your own car. You claim against the other driver's insurer. If that driver has no insurance, uninsured motorist property damage helps only if you bought it. In California it pays up to $3,500 when the driver or plate is identified.

Who pays for my rental car if I'm not at fault?

The other driver's insurer pays for a rental for a reasonable repair time once it accepts the claim, the Texas Department of Insurance says. If you claim through your own policy, a rental is covered only if you bought rental coverage.

Share ThisText ItLinkedInFacebook