After an accident, don't tell the insurer to use its shop, that its estimate looks fine, that the damage is just a bumper, that aftermarket parts are fine, that a total loss number works, or that you're done before you ask about lost value. Never pass old damage off as new. If you own a body shop, post those lines with the words to use instead. Injury firms hold this search and they barely mention the repair.
What Changed
- On the first page of Google for this search, 7 of 8 regular results came from injury law firms and none from a body shop in November 2026.
- California and Texas both bar an insurer from requiring a specific repair shop.
- AAA found safety sensors made up $684 of an average $1,698 repair after a minor rear hit.
- California lets an insurer require non original parts only if they are at least equal to the originals and the insurer warrants them.
- In Google Ads data Clickflame pulled in November 2026, car insurance claim runs $57.36 a click against $7.54 for collision repair near me.
- Never promise to eat a deductible on your site, and never coach a customer to add old damage.
Same Wreck, Two Phone Calls
One driver tells the adjuster, "Just send it to your shop. That estimate looks fine." Another says, "My shop will write its own estimate. Please send me yours." It's the same wreck and the same policy, but only one of them still has a say in the repair.
Neither driver said a word about fault. Most advice online never gets past fault.
On Google's first page for what not to tell your insurance company after an accident, 7 of the 8 regular results came from injury law firms in November 2026. The eighth was a Reddit thread. No body shop made the list. Google's AI answer covers apologies, injuries, guesses, medical records and recorded statements. The repair gets half a line.
Those firms have a job, and questions about fault and injuries belong with a lawyer. The car is your job. Seven short sentences can change who fixes the car and what it gets fixed with. Post them, and a driver meets your shop before the adjuster has picked one.
Seven Lines to Keep Off the Call
All seven are about the repair. Give your reader each line, the reason, and the words to use in its place.
1. Just Send It to Your Shop
California says an insurer cannot require a specific repair shop. It can recommend one only if the driver asks, or has been told in writing about the right to choose. Texas says the same about a list of preferred shops. In 2011 its regulator warned insurers that a notice implying extra cost at an unlisted shop may conflict with state law.
An insurer's network shop can still be the right pick. In California, the insurer must stand behind that shop's repairs. So the driver isn't wrong to choose it. The driver is wrong to choose it by accident.
Timing helps too. Once a California driver names a shop, the insurer may not suggest a different one, except as the law's referral rules allow.
Say instead. "I'm choosing my own shop, and I'll send you the name today."
2. That Estimate Looks Fine
A first estimate is written from a first look. California's guide says the adjuster writes it from the initial inspection, and the shop contacts the insurer if it finds more damage. Texas says the driver or the shop can ask the adjuster to raise it.
California drivers can get an independent estimate from a registered shop, even while a claim is open. They also get a copy of the insurer's estimate when a settlement is based on it. If a supplement comes in and the insurer wants another look, it has six business days to ask for the car and inspect it, as long as the car is reasonably available.
Say instead. "Please send me your estimate. My shop will look at the car and write its own."
3. It's Just a Bumper
Nobody knows that until the bumper comes off. AAA tested three 2023 models, and a minor rear hit averaged $1,698, with $684 of it going to safety sensors. In a side mirror replacement, the camera alone averaged $1,067. In a windshield job, the sensor parts averaged $360.
The bills add up fast on newer cars. The average collision claim was $5,489 in 2024, and $10,267 on 2022 to 2024 models.
Say instead. "I don't know the full damage yet. My shop will tell you after it looks."

4. Aftermarket Is Fine With Me
That may turn out to be true. A driver just shouldn't say it before seeing the parts list. California says aftermarket parts can equal or beat the originals. It also says an insurer can't require non original crash parts unless they are at least equal in kind, quality, safety, fit and performance, and the insurer warrants them in writing.
Texas works differently. Its bill of rights says the driver chooses the shop and parts, and the insurer doesn't have to pay more than a reasonable amount. Its guide adds that the insurer doesn't have to pay for original manufacturer parts. So a driver who wants them should ask early who pays the gap.
Say instead. "Which parts are on this estimate? Please list what's new, used and aftermarket."
5. That Total Loss Number Works
Don't say it on the first call. California bases the offer on the cost of a comparable car, itemized and explained in writing. If the driver reports within 35 days that the money won't buy a comparable car, the insurer reopens the file. Many policies also have an appraisal clause for fights over the number.
Texas tells drivers to be prepared to negotiate and to bring written price quotes on a similar car. A company might raise its offer if the car would really sell for more.
Say instead. "Please send the valuation in writing. I'll check it against similar cars."
6. It's Fixed, So We're Done
A car with a wreck on its record can be worth less, even after a good repair. Who pays for that depends on whose insurer it is. Texas says your own insurer isn't obligated to pay it once the car is completely repaired, but the other driver's insurer may owe it. A 2023 journal article found Georgia is the only state with clear direction in favor of claims against your own insurer, while many states pay when the claim is against the other driver.
Say instead. "Before I close this, I'd like to ask about the car's lost value."
7. That Old Dent Is From This Too
This is the one line that can turn a customer into a suspect. California lists reporting parts as damaged when they weren't among its auto fraud schemes.
The deductible is the same trap from the shop's side. New York's insurance regulator gave this example in 2007. A shop and insurer agree on $1,000, the deductible is $200, and the shop really charges $800. If the shop hides that and bills $1,000, it could be found to have committed fraud. Rules vary, and New York said some waivers may not break the law. Your website is still the wrong place to test that.
Say instead. "That door ding was already there. Please keep it separate from this claim."

California and Texas, Side by Side
A shop page that says "you have rights" tells a driver nothing. Name the state and link the rule. Two big states differ in the table below, built from the California and Texas pages cited above.
| Question | California | Texas |
|---|---|---|
| Can the insurer require its shop? | No | No |
| Can it suggest one? | If the driver asks, or was told in writing of the right to choose | It can give a list, but can't require the driver to pick from it |
| Non original parts? | Can be required only if equal to the originals and warranted | Driver chooses, insurer pays a reasonable amount |
| More damage found? | Shop asks for approval, insurer has six business days to re-inspect | Driver or shop asks the adjuster to raise the estimate |
| Total loss dispute? | Itemized offer in writing, 35 day window, appraisal if the policy has it | Negotiate with written quotes on similar cars |
Don't copy this table if you're in Ohio. Pull your own state's Department of Insurance page, put its rule in plain words, and date it.
Claim Questions Cost More Than Shop Searches
Clickflame pulled Google Ads data for these searches in November 2026, on U.S. monthly averages. Look at what people pay per click once a question turns to the claim.
| Search | Searches a month | Cost a click |
|---|---|---|
| car insurance claim | 3,600 | $57.36 |
| what not to say to insurance after accident | 40 | $39.12 |
| aftermarket parts insurance | 30 | $20.78 |
| what to say to insurance adjuster | 40 | $14.25 |
| diminished value claim | 8,100 | $11.20 |
| total loss settlement negotiation | 50 | $9.85 |
| collision repair near me | 74,000 | $7.54 |
| body shop near me | 301,000 | $6.35 |
The exact phrases are small, and lawyers likely push some of those prices up. So don't judge this page by its own traffic. Judge it by who reads it. A driver who asks what to say about a repair has a wrecked car and hasn't picked a shop. In that pull, car insurance claim costs about 7.6 times what collision repair near me does.
Plenty of those drivers are covered, too. Triple-I says 77% of drivers buy collision coverage, so an insurer is in most of these conversations from the first day.

Build the Claim Page in Six Steps
- Open with the answer. List the seven lines in the first screen. No shop history up top, and no line about serving the area since some year.
- Print your state's rules. Use a short table like the one above, with a link and a month beside each rule.
- Say where you stand. If you're on an insurer's network, say which one and what that means for the driver. If you aren't, explain how you work with any adjuster.
- Show a supplement. Show a real teardown with the customer's OK. Put the first estimate and the final one side by side, and explain the difference in plain words.
- Give them a card to save. Put the "say instead" lines on one short phone screen. Text it to anyone who calls from the side of the road.
- Put a real name on it. Google asks whether content shows first-hand expertise. A named estimator with real years in the trade beats an unsigned page. Local business schema helps Google read your shop details.
Two things stay off the page. Never promise to eat a deductible, and never hint that old damage can ride along. Don't trash insurers either. A lot of your work comes through them, and an adjuster may read it too.
Three Questions for the Front Desk
A driver with a fresh claim often calls a shop to ask one thing and needs help with another. Train the desk to ask these.
- Has anyone told you where to take the car?
- Are you claiming through your insurer or the other driver's?
- Have you signed anything or agreed to a number yet?
Then send the card and offer to look at the car. Your desk isn't a law office, so don't advise anyone on fault or injuries. If the car is close to a total, or the owner is asking whether it's worth fixing, walk them through the $3000 rule guide.
What Clickflame Adds to a Page Like This
When a repair shop hires Clickflame, a page like this opens with the plain answer and dated state rules, and the owner adds the real jobs. The call button goes to a tracked line, so the owner can see which questions turn into repair orders. The shop's Google Business Profile gets the same services.
See websites built for auto repair shops, or check where your shop stands now with the free local SEO grader.
Evidence
Every number in this story comes from one of these. If a figure is ours, the paragraph says so.
- California Department of Insurance, So You've Had an Accident, What's Next?
- California Code of Regulations, Title 10, Section 2695.8, Cornell Legal Information Institute
- California Code of Regulations, Title 10, Section 2695.85, Auto Body Repair Consumer Bill of Rights
- Texas Department of Insurance, Auto Insurance Guide
- Texas Department of Insurance, Consumer Bill of Rights, Personal Automobile Insurance
- Texas Department of Insurance, Commissioner's Bulletin B-0026-11 (June 20, 2011)
- Texas Department of Insurance, Commissioner's Bulletin B-0027-00, Payment of Diminished Value to Policyholders
- New York Insurance Department, OGC Opinion 07-10-05, Waiver of Deductible by an Automobile Collision Repair Facility (October 11, 2007)
- AAA Newsroom, Fixing Advanced Vehicle Systems Makes Up Over One-Third of Repair Costs Following a Crash (December 14, 2023)
- Insurance Information Institute, Facts and Statistics, Auto Insurance
- Journal of Insurance Regulation, Automobile Diminished Value Claims (NAIC, 2023)
- Google Search Central, Creating Helpful, Reliable, People-First Content
Clickflame builds the websites and runs the local search and ads for service businesses that live on the phone ringing. See websites built for auto repair shops, look at the work, or pick a time and we will look at your numbers with you.
Help Desk Answers
What should you not tell an insurance company after an accident?
On the repair side, don't tell it to use its shop, don't call its estimate fine, don't call the damage minor before a teardown, and don't accept parts or a total loss number you haven't seen in writing. Never claim old damage as new. Questions about fault and injuries belong with a lawyer.
Do I have to use the insurance company's body shop?
In California and Texas, no. Both states bar an insurer from requiring a specific shop. An insurer may still suggest one under the state's rules, and the driver may pick it on purpose. Check your own state's Department of Insurance for its rule.
Can a body shop waive my deductible?
It depends on the state and the facts. New York's insurance regulator wrote in 2007 that a shop could commit fraud if it waives a deductible, hides that from the insurer and still bills the full agreed price. A shop should not advertise this.
Can insurance make me use aftermarket parts?
It depends on the state. California lets an insurer require them only if they are at least equal to the originals and the insurer warrants them. Texas says an insurer may not specify the parts, but it does not have to pay more than a reasonable amount.
Should a body shop write about what to tell insurance?
Yes, if you stay on the repair. Cover the shop choice, the estimate, the parts and the total loss. Link each rule to the state page that says it. Send fault and injury questions to a lawyer, because that isn't your trade.
What should a body shop put on a claim page?
Put the seven lines first, then your state's rules with links, how a supplement works in your shop, whether you are on any insurer's network, and a short phone script a driver can save. Add real teardown photos if the customer agrees.



