A site can sit at the top of the results and produce almost nothing. When that happens the owner usually buys more traffic, which makes the problem more expensive rather than smaller. Ranking and converting are separate problems. Here are the seven reasons we see most, in the order they cost the most money.
You Do Not Say What It Costs
This is first because it is first by a distance. Every trade has one question the customer will not ask out loud and will not buy without. What does it cost.
The usual objection is that every job is different. That is true and it is not an answer. A range is an answer. What changes the number is an answer. Silence is what sends a careful customer to whoever is willing to say something, and careful customers are the good ones.
Look at A Plus Auto Detail. The service menu carries the price and how long the car is gone for. That is unusual in detailing, which is exactly why it works.
The Phone Number Is Hiding
On a phone, without scrolling, on every page. Tap to call, so it dials when touched. Not an image. Not only in the footer. Not behind a contact page.
This sounds too obvious to mention and it is wrong on a large share of the service sites we look at, usually because a designer felt the number cluttered the header. The number is the product. Everything else on the page exists to get someone to press it.
It Is Slow on a Phone
Test it on a real phone, on cell data, outdoors. Not on office wifi in a desktop browser, which is how almost everyone tests and why almost everyone thinks their site is fast.
Four things cause most of it. Huge unoptimized photos. A review widget loading from somewhere else. A chat bubble nobody uses. A font that blocks the page from painting. Fixing those four usually does more than a redesign.
Slow pages do not just lose the slow half of visitors. They lose the visitors in a hurry, and in the trades the visitors in a hurry are the emergency jobs, which are the ones that pay best and shop least.
Nobody Knows Who Turns Up
A stock photo of a smiling person with a clipboard tells the customer nothing, and in several trades it actively signals the thing they are trying to avoid. Locksmith customers have learned to screen for national lead brokers. Roofing customers after a storm have learned to screen for crews that will not be here next month.
Show the actual person. The actual van. The actual crew. A one person operation should say so, because being visibly the person who turns up is an advantage over a call center, not a limitation.
You Never Say What Happens Next
People hesitate because they do not know what they are starting. Will someone come out today. Is the estimate free. How long does it take. Will they be pressured. Do they need to be home.
Write it down. Four sentences on what happens after they call removes more hesitation than any testimonial, because it addresses the actual fear, which is not about quality. It is about being trapped in a process.
The Page Answers the Wrong Question
This one hides behind good rankings, which is what makes it expensive. A page can rank for a term whose searchers wanted something the page does not offer, and the traffic looks healthy right up until you notice it never converts.
The commonest version in the trades is mixing two customers on one page. Emergency and planned work are not the same person. A burst pipe at 11pm and a bathroom remodel are the same trade and nothing like the same buyer. One wants a number and an answer. The other wants photos, financing and time. A page built for both serves neither, which is why our plumbing page splits them and says so.
The same is true of repair against replacement in HVAC, and of a broken spring against a new door in garage doors.
Nobody Answers
The last one is not on the website at all and it is probably the largest. The site works. The customer calls. Nobody picks up, because it is 7pm and everyone is on a job or asleep.
A missed call in the trades is usually a lost job, not a delayed one. The customer is already dialing the next result before your voicemail finishes. Most service businesses lose more work this way than to every ranking problem combined, and almost none of them count it.
The fix does not have to be a person. Something that texts back inside a minute, asks the two questions that qualify the job, and wakes a human when the answer warrants it will recover most of them. What it must never do is quote a price nobody approved, or pretend to be a person when it is not.
Count last month's missed calls. Multiply by your average job value. Compare that to your marketing budget. For most shops the first number is larger, and it is the cheapest thing on this page to fix.
We build the website and we host it, at no cost. SEO starts at $800 a month, month to month, and that is the whole invoice. Before you pay anything we will build your real site and send you the link. Here is how that works.
Common Questions
What is a good conversion rate for a service business website?
It varies enormously by trade and by intent. The more useful measure is your own last quarter. If traffic rose and calls did not, the problem is on the page, not in the rankings.
Should I put prices on my website?
Ranges, yes, almost always. The customers who need an exact number will call anyway. The ones who need to know the order of magnitude will leave if you say nothing, and they are the majority.
Does live chat increase calls?
Sometimes, and it often costs more in load time than it returns. Test it honestly. A chat bubble nobody uses is one of the four things that most commonly makes a service site slow.
How fast does a site need to be to convert?
Under a second to first paint on a phone on cell data is the target we build to. For emergency trades it is not a nicety. The customer is calling whoever answers first.
What is the cheapest conversion fix?
Answering the phone. Most service businesses lose more work to unanswered calls than to anything on their website, and almost none of them count it.